Best Pizza in Beckley, WV: Why Little Sicily Tops the List

Craving the best pizza in Beckley, WV? Little Sicily serves fresh New York-style pizza, from classic Margherita to loaded specialty pies.

Little Sicily in Beckley, WV is the best pizza in the area, offering hand-crafted, New York-style pies made fresh daily by a chef with over 20 years of experience. Each pizza is made fresh with quality mozzarella and a house-made sauce, from the classic Margherita to loaded specialty pies like Meat Lovers and BBQ Chicken. Available for dine-in, carry-out, and delivery at 3144 Robert C. Byrd Dr., Beckley, WV.

Beckley has no shortage of places to grab a bite, but on the subject of pizza night, one name keeps coming up again and again: Little Sicily. From feeding the whole family, ordering in for a quiet night at home, or just craving a proper slice, here’s why locals keep coming back.

If you’ve searched “best pizza near me” or “best pizza in Beckley WV,” here’s what actually makes a pizza worth ordering, and why Little Sicily comes up consistently as the local favourite.

What Makes a Pizza the "Best" in Beckley?

Not all pizza is created equal, and "best" isn't just a marketing word; it comes down to a few concrete things:

  • Fresh, made-from-scratch dough, not frozen or pre-made
  • Quality mozzarella and sauce – made in-house, not a short-cut blend
  • Not just a fast food assembly line, but a real pizza chef
  • Variety – classic styles, specialty and family choices
  • Consistency – the same delicious pie every time you order

New York Style Pizza in Beckley: What Sets It Apart

Little Sicily is known for New York-style pizza: a thin, hand-tossed, crunchy outside and foldable middle with a well-balanced ratio of sauce, cheese, and toppings instead of an overloaded pie. It's the style most people think of when they think of "real" pizzeria pizza, not the deep-dish or fast-food chain styles that rely on thick crust and processed toppings.

This is important for taste and texture: a good New York slice lets the ingredients speak for themselves, the philosophy Little Sicily's kitchen takes with its whole Italian menu, not just the pizza. Do you wonder where pizza comes from? Check out our guide: Is Pizza Italian Food?

The Full Pizza Menu at Little Sicily

Here's the complete pizza lineup, available in 10", 14", and 16" sizes:

A few standouts worth trying

Margherita

Fresh basil, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, shredded mozzarella. The simplest pizza on the menu, and often the best way to gauge a pizzeria's true skill.

BBQ Chicken

Chicken, bacon, BBQ sauce, onions, jalapeños, feta and mozzarella. If you're looking for something other than classic red-sauce pizza, go bold and non-traditional.

White Pizza

Spinach, mushrooms, garlic, mozzarella, ricotta and kalamata olives. No tomato sauce, all built on garlic and cheese flavour.

Greek Pizza

Feta, mozzarella, spinach, tomatoes, olives, olive oil, garlic, and red onions give a Mediterranean twist to the classic list of toppings.

Best Pizza for Families, Date Night, or Takeout

Little Sicily's pizza works for more than one occasion:

  • Family dinner: The 16" sizes are designed for sharing, and a Kids Menu is offered alongside the full pizza lineup for family visits.
  • Date night or a quiet night in: A 10" Margherita or White pizza sizes well for two, paired with a glass of wine from the menu.
  • Group orders and parties: The Supreme or Meat Lovers 16" pizzas are popular for larger gatherings, and catering is available for larger events.
  • Fast weeknight order: Both carry-out and delivery options are available, so you can get a fresh pizza without sitting down to dine in.

The best pizza is often a matter of taste, but the basics are always the same: good dough, real ingredients, and a chef who knows his stuff. That's what Little Sicily serves up in each pie, whether it's a plain Margherita or a fully loaded Meat Lovers. If you're in Beckley and haven't tried it yet, this is the pizza to build your next pizza night around.

Visit Little Sicily for Beckley's best pizza. Offering up the classic Margherita, the loaded Meat Lovers, or something a little different like the White or Greek pizza, Little Sicily brings authentic, made-fresh pizza to Beckley, WV. Order online, call for carry-out, or come in for dine-in at 3144 Dr. Robert C. Byrd Dr., Beckley, WV. Ready to order? Stop in today or call (304) 255-4976 to see why we have the best pizza in town, Beckley.

Back to Blog

Contact Little Sicily

Address: 3144 Robert C Byrd Dr, Beckley, WV 25801.

Phone: (304) 255-4976.

Email: Mohamed.farghaly1@gmail.com.

Hours: Monday-Thursday 11:00am-9:30pm; Friday-Saturday 11:00am-10:30pm; Sunday 11:00am-9:00pm.